Growth Mindset: What has attitude got to do with IQ?

Rory McIlroy, one of the world's best golfers, has suffered in the golf course, especially at Augusta (Picture Source: Irish Times)
Rory McIlroy, one of the world’s best golfers, has suffered on the golf course, especially at Augusta (Picture Source: Irish Times)

 

It is almost seven years since Rory McIroy carded 80 in the final round of Augusta to derail his chances of winning the Green Jacket. I remember watching Rory striding down the fairways of Augusta, a bounce in his stride on his way to don the Green Jacket and win a Grand Slam.

Then over the space of four holes his potential victory evaporated.

The world saw the 21-year-old bury his face in the crook of his elbow, as victory slipped away. I also remember clearly his subsequent interview, his attitude and maturity in reflecting that if that was the worst thing that happened to him life would be good, that he had learned many valuable lessons from his “meltdown”. Rory picked himself up, dusted himself down and two months later won the US Open.

So, what has Rory’s experience got to do with intelligence?
.

Intelligence isn’t just brain cells

The traditional view of intelligence suggested that individuals had no control over their intellectual potential. IQ and other intelligence tests sent out the message to every individual including those who scored well was that your intelligence was something you were given and not something you earned.

Furthermore, this view limited intelligence to abilities such as logic, problem solving skills, verbal reasoning and spatial awareness. Over time this definition of intelligence was challenged, and it was suggested that intelligence is more multidimensional than originally proposed. Gardner’s (Harvard psychologist Howard Gardner) theory of multiple intelligences originally suggested seven intelligences; he then added a further two.

He suggests that intelligence includes the traditional abilities such as linguistic, logical/mathematical, spatial and also intelligences such as bodily (athletic), musical, interpersonal and intrapersonal and subsequently he added spiritual, existential, moral intelligence is also being considered.
.

Fixed and growth mindset

Carol Dweck
Carol Dweck

Whilst all these factors are important, Carol Dweck’s work on fixed mindset and growth mindset opens up a different perspective on intelligence.

Over the last 20 years Carol Dweck and her colleague studied attitudes in young children in relation to learning and problem solving. They questioned what was the reason that some children embraced challenges around learning whilst others strove to demonstrate their ability through performance and getting the right answer rather than appearing to ‘fail’ and then try and try again.

With the use of fMRIs and PETscans and progress in medicine we now understand much more about how the brain works and that it has plasticity that can grow, develop and change. This plasticity is present from a very early age and, although it diminishes with age, we now understand that it is possible to train our brain to serve us better.

The knowledge that our brain is plastic and that a growth mindset means that our attitude to learning can change – we can see things differently.

Indeed, old dogs can learn new tricks with the right attitude.


Maura_Dolan-1.jpgMaura Dolan is an IMI Associate Faculty member, an accredited fellow of coaching (AFC) facilitator and trainer with over 14 years’ experience coaching senior executives, designing and delivering coach training courses. Prior to establishing Life & Executive Coaching Institute, Maura spent over 20 years working in the corporate world and has extensive business acumen.