Placing Our Bets Part 1: Leading Through Uncertainty with Laurence Knell

By Ben Davern

Read part 2 here and part 3 here.

If 2025 did anything, it stripped away the comforting illusion that “normal” is a stable state. There seemed to be a growing (if overdue) acceptance that we must wave goodbye, once and for all, to any pretence that volatility is an occasional disruption rather than the regular operating climate.

Just look at the overlapping pressures leaders are navigating: geopolitical instability, trade and regulatory uncertainty complexity, shifting energy realities, rapid technological adoption (and knowing when not to adopt), talent constraints, changing stakeholder expectations due to the political climate, and so on.

Considering how many of these forces sit outside an organisation’s control, the differentiator for 2026 is unlikely to be who predicts best but rather who prepares best; namely, who turns ambiguity into some form of direction, converts technology into digital advantage, who builds performance that lasts, and who does it all without burning out their people or their reputation.

A useful way to think about the year ahead: not as a set of economic or revenue forecasts, but as a set of leadership themes. Four stand out, tightly aligned to IMI’s Leadership Model: leading through uncertainty, seizing the digital advantage, reimagining high performance, with all three held together by the wider imperative of sustainable performance.

In part 1 of this series, we look at the next twelve months through the lens of leading through uncertainty below.

Leading Through Uncertainty 

“In unsettled conditions, the most common leadership failure isn’t necessarily making the wrong call,” says Laurence Knell, Programme Director for IMI’s Professional Diploma in Leading Change and Transformation, “But freezing, overanalysing or waiting for information that never arrives.

Uncertainty exposes the limits of traditional leadership habits, believes Knell. Many leaders were trained to always provide answers, to build multi-year plans and forecasts, and execute according to traditional project management metrics. “But these were the hallmarks of a linear world that bears little resemblance to our current climate,” says Knell.

Directional Clarity

Increasingly, leaders are required to create directional clarity without any pretence towards certainty, which is a paradigm shift in leadership that doesn’t get discussed enough. Although cliches about “uncertainty” and the “new normal” are repeated ad nauseum, many leaders are still role-playing an answers-based style of leadership rather than one that’s questions-based, like this was the previous century and a more stable time—potentially a coping mechanism to avoid being totally overwhelmed by the high-levels of uncertainty and complexity they’re required to lead through.

Indeed, while it may seem hypocritical to predict what the “best” leaders will do, if we’re placing our bets it seems likely that the best leaders in 2026 will be those who can help teams make sense of conflicting signals, make decisions with imperfect data and information, and stay coherent as circumstances change.

Decision Principles and Learning Loops

That shift is practical as well as philosophical, according to Knell.

“Organisations that perform well through uncertainty are not necessarily those with the most detailed plans or strategies,” says Knell, “But rather those with the clearest decision principles and fastest learning loops. They know what they are optimising for, they’re explicit about trade-offs, and they communicate often enough that people don’t fill the vacuum with anxiety and speculation.

“In 2026, I would go as far as saying that leaders who treat trust and communication as a form of operational infrastructure—something to design and maintain, not something to assume—will gain a major competitive advantage, especially considering the environment that surrounds them, where headlines are noisy and confidence can turn all too quickly.”

Optionality and Adaptability

We see this play out in the field of global trade and geopolitics, which shows the challenges of leading through uncertainty when the rules keep moving. At the same time, trade and policy swings serve as a reminder that strategy can’t rely on a single “right” future. When tariffs, currency movements, industrial policy and regulatory shifts are in play, we see at a practical level how leadership cannot be about predicting, and becomes more about designing adaptability and embedding it into business models.

To build upon an earlier point that leading through uncertainty crucially involves building organisations with faster sense-making and clearer decision rights, the winners here are set to be those teams with the highest optionality, e.g. alternative suppliers, different routes to market, flexible pricing logic, and scenario triggers that prompt action before panic sets in. In what we may consider a three-way feedback loop, increased optionality might the best way to embed resilience into business models and create maximum value.

A Cultural Advantage

“But the deeper leadership point is cultural,” says Knell. “Uncertainty tests whether people feel safe enough to surface bad news early, whether decisions can move without bottlenecks, and whether leaders communicate in a way that lowers noise rather than amplifies it. In such volatile trade conditions, that sort of ‘calm clarity’ becomes a very powerful tool for performance and should not be underestimated.”

Geopolitics and global dynamics are the ultimate reminder that leaders must act like translators.

“This isn’t so much about holding daily briefings with employees,” says Knell, “But helping them to understand what a changing world means for their customers, their work and their future.”

Leadership maturity will show up in how organisations hold tension: being realistic without becoming fatalistic, preparing without catastrophising, and acting without any pretence of the certainty that characterised a previous era.

“At the same time, creating ‘stability anchors,’ or what stays true when conditions shift, will be crucial here,” says Knell, “Along with building the muscle to redeploy resources quickly when assumptions break—and that is when, and not if.”

Read Part 2 in this series, Seizing the Digital Advantage with Kieran Gilmurray, here.

Read Part 3 in this series, Reimagining High Performance with Nina Noonan, here.