Placing Our Bets Part 3: Reimagining High Performance with Nina Noonan

By Ben Davern

Read part 1 here and read part 2 here.

If 2025 did anything, it stripped away the comforting illusion that “normal” is a stable state. There seemed to be a growing (if overdue) acceptance that we must wave goodbye, once and for all, to any pretence that volatility is an occasional disruption rather than the regular operating climate.

Just look at the overlapping pressures leaders are navigating: geopolitical instability, trade and regulatory uncertainty complexity, shifting energy realities, rapid technological adoption (and knowing when not to adopt), talent constraints, changing stakeholder expectations due to the political climate, and so on.

Considering how many of these forces sit outside an organisation’s control, the differentiator for 2026 is unlikely to be who predicts best but rather who prepares best; namely, who turns ambiguity into some form of direction, converts technology into digital advantage, who builds performance that lasts, and who does it all without burning out their people or their reputation.

A useful way to think about the year ahead: not as a set of economic or revenue forecasts, but as a set of leadership themes. Four stand out, tightly aligned to IMI’s Leadership Model: leading through uncertainty, seizing the digital advantage, reimagining high performance, with all three held together by the wider imperative of sustainable performance.

In part 3 of this series, we look at the next twelve months through the lens of reimagining high performance.

Reimagining High Performance

For years, many organisations equated high performance with intensity: more pace, higher targets, tighter timelines, always-on availability. But much like an athlete, intensity without recovery doesn’t produce excellence; it produces fragility. Placing our bets for 2026, the organisations that succeed are set to be those who build high performance as a system—repeatable, resilient and scalable—rather than a heroic burst of effort.

This reimagining, if you will, starts with “clarity,” says Nina Noonan, IMI Programme Director and Senior Associate Faculty.

“Teams will struggle to perform if priorities are crowded and trade-offs remain unspoken,” says Noonan. “The world is complex enough without additional and unnecessary complexity around communication. But this requires better teaming across functions—complexity punishes silos—with leaders needing to strengthen the ‘middle layer’ of their organisations in particular, i.e. the managers and functional leaders who translate strategy into delivery, because this is where execution tends to either accelerate or clog.”

And coaching will matter more than ever, according to Noonan, since skills are changing too quickly for command-and-control approaches to keep up. Compounding advantage will come from leaders being able to create environments where standards are high and people feel safe enough to speak up, challenge and learn from each other.

Performance as a Confidence Game

If one thinks about how financial stocks often reflect confidence in the cycle, leaders can apply an equivalent lesson: performance is something of a confidence game. When teams trust the organisation’s direction and fairness, they move faster. When they don’t, everything slows—more checking, more politics, more defensive work disguised as diligence.

So when we talk about ‘reimagining’ high performance,” says Noonan, “This means shifting away from “more intensity” and towards repeatable execution: fewer but more clearly communicated priorities, which are also more high-value priorities, along with shorter feedback loops and the discipline to stop work that no longer earns its place.”

It also means confronting something most organisations avoid: many performance problems are actually design problems, e.g. unclear accountability, competing KPIs, too many decision-makers, or incentives that reward local optimisation over enterprise value.

By contrast, strong leaders—meaning impactful leaders, rather than having any association with an authoritarian style of leadership—will treat confidence as something to be built deliberately through transparency, consistent standards and visible follow-through.

High Performance Under Disruption

This is especially important within the context of disruption, according to Noonan. Disruption is rarely linear, and markets punish both overconfidence and denial. AI adoption, energy transition choices, workforce strategy and consumer trust are set to continue in their domination of business headlines.

“Reimagining high performance here means building organisations that can absorb shocks without swinging between extremes,” says Noonan. “It means leaders who can say ‘we’re committed, and we’re adapting,’ instead of “we’re doubling down no matter what” or ‘we’re abandoning ship.’”

But it also means recognising that reputation is an operating asset. In our highly scrutinised social media era, set against a backdrop of political volatility that constantly threatens to boil over, leadership behaviour and brand perception are tightly linked. “Once trust erodes, says Noonan, “Performance usually follows.”

Read Part 1 in this series, Leading Through Uncertainty With Laurence Knell, here. 

Read Part 2 in this series, Seizing the Digital Advantage with Kieran Gilmurray, here.