Five hidden costs of treating mentoring as optional – and what this means for Irish competitiveness
Mentoring has often been framed as a positive extra, something useful for development, good for engagement, helpful for talent, and great for employer branding.
That framing is too soft.
In an increasingly volatile, high-pressure environment, the real challenge for many organisations is not necessarily lack of ambition. It is whether they have enough leadership capacity, judgement and internal capability to execute under intense pressure.
Skills development is increasingly tied to productivity and growth, as the recent OECD Skills Outlook makes clear, while IMI’s recent Leadership Pulse points to a similar conclusion: competitiveness is being won or lost in how leadership teams prioritise, decide and execute — and when leadership teams cannot convert strategy into repeatable execution, organisational throughput suffers.
That is why mentoring deserves to be taken more seriously. Not because it is nice-to-have, but because it helps build the leadership depth, capability transfer and execution readiness that performance increasingly depends on. These are business challenges with real economic impacts, going far beyond L&D.
- It slows down leadership readiness
One of the most immediate costs of weak mentoring is slower readiness for bigger roles.
Many organisations assume they have stronger benches than they really do. IMI’s From Insight to Impact whitepaper warns that leadership development can create “false positives” in succession planning, where individuals look prepared on paper but are less ready in high-pressure, complex situations than their profiles suggest. It also argues that awareness without applied skill-building can reinforce theory over execution.
That matters because succession risk rarely announces itself early. It tends to show up later — when a bigger role opens, a transformation initiative accelerates, or a decision needs to be made without a long runway for learning. Mentoring helps narrow that gap by giving emerging leaders access to lived judgement before they are exposed at the next level.
- “Supportive” cultures stop short of real capability-building
Many organisations have improved significantly at creating more supportive, inclusive team environments. But support is not the same thing as development.
Recent IMI research shows leaders report relatively strong confidence in building inclusive and psychologically safe teams, confidence drops sharply when it comes to enabling individual growth through structured coaching and mentoring. Only 11% rated themselves as expert in using coaching and mentoring techniques, and less than 40% rated themselves good or very good. Based on this research, we concluded that many leaders know how to offer verbal support, but are less clear on how to develop others in a structured way.
That distinction is critical. A positive climate can improve trust, but without challenge, stretch and development, capability can plateau.
- Critical know-how walks out the door instead of compounding
Formal systems matter, but in many organisations the most valuable capability still sits in people: judgement, pattern recognition, stakeholder instinct and the ability to make sound calls under pressure.
Mentoring is one of the simplest ways to transfer that capability deliberately rather than leaving it to chance. Otherwise that know-how is less likely to be transferred deliberately and more likely to leave informally. That creates a double cost: organisations lose valuable experience, while less experienced leaders take longer to build the judgement they need.
This is especially relevant in a challenging macro environment where complexity is rising, execution is under pressure, and retaining critical know-how is becoming harder. IMI’s Leadership Pulse warns that when leadership teams cannot make trade-offs effectively, decisions slow, rework rises, transformation ROI weakens and retaining critical capability becomes harder. Teams may also look healthy on the surface, but still be under-challenged, under-developed and carrying hidden capability gaps.
Put simply, when mentoring is weak, knowledge leaves faster than it compounds.
- Execution suffers because the “people side” of performance is underbuilt
Mentoring is often discussed as a development tool. It is more useful to think of it as an execution tool.
Recent IMI research points to the same challenge: leaders often understand what needs to change, but struggle to act with enough speed and clarity, indicating a persistent gap between awareness and applied capability. This has ramifications for Ireland’s competitiveness, which increasingly depends on decision speed, trade-offs, behavioural discipline and cross-functional execution at both the organisational and national levels.
That is where mentoring becomes strategically relevant. It helps transfer judgement, strengthen confidence, and shorten the time between insight and action.
External evidence supports that broader point. Prosci’s change management research finds that organisations with excellent change management are about seven times more likely to meet objectives than those with poor change management, reinforcing the wider lesson that when the people side of change is weak, delivery suffers.
- It weakens competitiveness at exactly the wrong time
The strongest reason to rethink mentoring is that the wider environment has changed.
Ireland’s competitiveness is increasingly constrained by slow decisions, weak cross-functional habits, unclear ownership and execution drag. In this context, capability transfer is a competitiveness lever.
That phrasing matters. It moves mentoring and coaching out of the category of “good HR practice” and much closer to the categories of execution, resilience and business performance. IMI’s focus on the linked nature between capability and competitiveness also aligns with Ireland’s own Action Plan on Competitiveness and Productivity, which frames resilience, agility and future-readiness as national priorities.
This is also consistent with wider research. CIPD notes coaching and mentoring can enhance employees’ skills, knowledge and performance and should be linked to overall learning and development strategy rather than treated as isolated activity. OECD’s recent skills work similarly underlines how economic and organisational performance depend on how effectively essential skills are developed and deployed. And PwC’s 28th Annual Global CEO Survey found that almost 42% of CEOs believed their company would not be viable beyond the next decade without reinvention.
That is the real backdrop for this conversation.
The question has changed
The question cannot be whether mentoring is a worthwhile development initiative.
The real question is whether organisations can afford the cost of leaving leadership readiness, capability transfer and future performance to chance.
In a more demanding economy, mentoring is not a perk. It is one of the practical ways organisations build stronger benches, retain know-how, accelerate readiness and improve their odds of executing well under pressure.
Network Mentor Programme
The IMI/30% Club Network Mentor Programme is a practical response to exactly these challenges. A critical leadership development opportunity and a key element of human capital strategy, the programme is designed to strengthen talent capability through a cross-company, cross-sector mentoring network that brings together experienced leaders and high-potential professionals.
In the context of IMI’s own research — which shows that competitiveness is increasingly shaped by decision speed, execution discipline, behaviour change and capability transfer, and that many leaders are still more confident creating supportive climates than coaching and mentoring others to sustained performance — the NMP should be viewed as a critical part of the leadership infrastructure that helps organisations build stronger benches, retain know-how, accelerate readiness and improve business performance under pressure.
Email [email protected] to enquire about the next run of the IMI/30% Club Network Mentor Programme.